Economic Aid to Post-conflict Countries: A Methodological Critique of Collier and Hoeffler.
This paper retests the analysis of "Aid Policy and Growth in Post-Conflict Societies," by Paul Collier and Anke Hoeffler (October 2002 and forthcoming in European Economic Review). It finds that their data and analysis do not support their conclusions and policy recommendations on the optimal timing and amounts of aid. These conclusions depend on very few observations (13 for the period of peace-onset, 13 for years 4 to 7 when a growth spurt is said to make aid particularly effective, and 8 for the period when aid should taper off); are vulnerable to the same methodological misspecifications identified in the Burnside and Dollar approach on which this analysis is based; and are not grounded in any theoretical formulation about the special relation between aid and growth in post-conflict conditions. Conventional econometric procedures are often not followed; recoding the sample to exclude cases that are not civil wars reduces the effect of aid on growth in post-civil war countries to less than half of what they claim; and the difference with the relationship for "normal" countries becomes negligible (0.26 percentage points), although it depends on identification of the sample. Their claims on the poverty-efficiency of aid are assumed, not analysed. The confidentiality of their policy measure (CPIA) prevented testing the aid-policy relationship.
Recent CMI publications:
From asylum seekers to kin: The making and effects of kinship between Norwegian citizens and migrants
Heidi Mogstad, Thea Rabe
Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies
Increasing the adoption of safe sanitation infrastructure: Evidence from India
Britta Augsburg, Bet Caeyers, Bansi Malde, Sara Giunti, Harriet Olorenshaw, Zaki Wakhaj
Dietary patterns and their association with cardiovascular risk factors in Ethiopia: A community-based cross-sectional study
Wondimagegn Paulos Kumma, Eskindir Loha
Frontiers in Nutrition
Kunnskap eller forsoning?
Senter for samiske studier Skriftserie nr. 23
A Regional Insight into Sudanese Women’s Participation in the December Revolution
Yusra Elmobashir Abdalla, Hajir Hamad Bashir, Isalam Adam Omer Mohammed, Zeinab Onour Mohamed Adam Hanaa Inbrahiem Al Tirifi, Safaa Yasir Babiker, Amal Ahmad Hamed Batio
Is there legal pluralism in Afghanistan? Notes on injustice and access to justice
Antonio De Lauri
Water segregation, water disconnection and human rights litigation: An examination of the use of law to challenge structural racism in Detroit and Johannesburg
A Research Agenda for Human Rights and the Environment
Abortion, law and health in the Arab world
Irene Maffi and Liv Tønnessen
International Abortion Law: A Research Handbook