Engineering gender equality: The effects of aid to women's political representation
While the number of women holding parliamentary seats is slowly growing globally from 10% in 1995 to 17% in 2009, Africa is on the ‘fast track’ to women’s political representation.The number of female parliamentarians in African legislative assemblies has more than doubled since the Beijing Platform for Action from 1995 which called upon governments to “take positive action to build a critical mass of women leaders, executives and managers in strategic decision-making positions”. The critical mass was established at 30% seats for women in parliament.Currently Rwanda has the highest percentage of women in parliament in the world at 64 % outshining all of the Nordic countries.
The last decade, women’s political empowerment has been the biggest target area of Norwegian aid to women’s rights and gender equality with seven African countries on the top-10 list of gender marked Norwegian aid recipients, namely Ethiopia, Malawi, Mozambique, Tanzania, Sudan, Uganda, and Zambia. The theory of change underpinning this aid is that increasing the number of women (descriptive representation) in political decision-making processes is important for its own sake, but it is additionally regarded as a powerful tool to fight gendered laws, attitudes and injustices more generally. In short, it is expected to increase pro-women initiatives, acts and legislative outcomes (substantive representation) and to change patriarchal attitudes and make public perceptions more favourable towards women in politics (symbolic representation).
Recent studies of a related phenomenon, democracy assistance, have found that aid is clearly more effective in preventing backlash in newly democratized states, than fostering transitions from autocratic to democratic regimes. Based on this logic, the project explores whether gendered aid is most efficient in countries where there is a high degree of descriptive representation and a visible women’s movement to push and support female legislators to act in the interest of women. In these cases gender equality assistance might bring about processes that make descriptive representation effective in translating numbers into women’s substantive and symbolic representation. When, where and how is gendered aid most effective?
This project looks at the effects of aid on women's substantive (acting for women) and symbolic (role-modeling women) representation in Malawi, Sudan, Uganda and Zambia from 2007 until 2013. The starting point is 2007, when we saw a massive increase in Norwegian aid to women’s political empowerment in Africa. All the cases are main recipients of gendered Norwegian aid, but they clearly differ when it comes to both the visibility of women’s movements and descriptive representation. Whereas Uganda had a strong women’s movement and 31 % women in the national assembly in 2007, Malawi, Sudan and Zambia had weak women’s movements and low levels of descriptive representation. Yet, we know that since 2007 the cases represent uneven trajectories of developments in women’s descriptive, substantive and possibly also symbolic representation. How has gendered aid contributed in these processes? Besides building new empirical knowledge about the effects of aid to women’s political empowerment in previously understudied cases, the principle endeavor of this research is to generate new hypotheses about women’s substantive and symbolic representation, and in this way facilitate theory development and building a stronger base for informed policy.
Paper tiger law forbidding FGM in Sudan
Liv Tønnessen, Samia El-Nagar, Sharifa Gafar Bamkar
It Takes a Female Chief: Gender and Effective Policy Advocacy in Malawi
Ragnhild L. Muriaas, Vibeke Wang, Lindsay J. Benstead, Boniface Dulani and Lise Rakner
Using Traditional Leaders to End Child Marriage: Evidence from a survey experiment in Malawi
Lindsay Benstead, Boniface Dulani, Ragnhild Muriaas, Lise Rakner, Vibeke Wang
Quotas and Women's Substantive Representation: Evidence from a Content Analysis of Ugandan Plenary Debates
Amanda Clayton, Cecilia Josefsson and Vibeke Wang
Politics & Gender
Does Western Donor Affiliation Help or Hurt? Public Opinion toward Public and Private Rights of Women in Malawi
Lindsay Benstead, Ragnhild Muriaas, Vibeke Wang
Reserved Seats for Women in Parliament: A Comparative Study of Tanzania and Uganda
Vibeke Wang, Mi Yung Yoon
Women Acting for Women? Electoral Rules and Women's Substantive Representation
Amanda Clayton, Cecilia Josefsson, Vibeke Wang
Bistand til kvinnebevegelser i Afrika virker
Ragnhild Muriaas, Liv Tønnessen og Vibeke Wang
Present without Presence? Gender, Quotas, and Debate Recognition in the Ugandan Parliament
Amanda Clayton, Cecilia Josefsson, Vibeke Wang
A Comparative Analysis of Policy Processes to Address Violence Against Women in Malawi and Uganda
Putting Women's Rights on the Agenda: A Comparative Analysis of Domestic Violence Policy Processes in Malawi and Uganda
Engineering gender equality: A presentation of research design on the effects of aid to women's political representation
Redefining the Traditional and Religious State: Framing Child Marriage Reform in Sudan and Zambia
Ragnhild Muriaas, Liv Tønnessen and Vibeke Wang
Women’s Rights and the Women’s Movement in Sudan (1952-2014): Focus and Strategies for Adopting Legal Feminist Action
Samia al-Nagar and Liv Tønnessen
Women's activism in Africa
Gender and Political and Economic Inequality
Lovise Aalen, Ragnhild Muriaas, Liv Tønnessen, Vibeke Wang
Criminalizing Female Genital Mutilation in Sudan: A never ending story?
Liv Tønnessen and Samia al-Nagar
Law Reform in Post-Conflict Sudan: Are Female Members of the National Assembly Acting in the Interest of Sudanese Women?
The Ahfad Journal:Women and Change
Tracing Gender Differences in Parliamentary Debates: A Growth Curve Analysis of Ugandan MPs' Activity Levels in Plenary Sessions, 1998-2008.
Governance and Fiscal Federalism in Sudan, 1989–2015: Exploring Political and Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations in an Unstable Polity
Atta El-Hassan El-Battahani, Hassan Ali Gadkarim
Enemies of the State: Curbing Women Activists Advocating Rape Reform in Sudan
Journal of International Women's Studies
Sudan: Human rights, development and democracy
Politics in the Developing World
Weak law forbidding female genital mutilation in Red Sea State, Sudan
Samia al-Nagar, Liv Tønnessen, Sharifa Bamkar
The Pitfalls of Protection. Gender, Violence and Power in Afghanistan